When Making Friends as an Adult Feels Impossible and What Jesus Is Teaching Me Through It

I don’t know about you, but making friends as an adult woman has felt surprisingly hard. Not “slightly inconvenient” hard. I’m talking, standing in a crowded room, feeling completely invisible, kind of hard. I don’t think anyone prepared us for this part of life. The part where we’re juggling families, work, responsibilities, schedules, and the desire for connection all at the same time. 

When I was younger, friendships seemed to form without effort. You sat next to someone in class, played on the same team, or had something small in common, and boom, suddenly, you were inseparable. But somewhere between motherhood, responsibilities, faith, hurt, and exhaustion, connection stopped being simple. Friendship became something that required intention and courage. And honestly? This year, friendship has felt like one of the hardest things in my life.

Today, I want to share something personal. Something vulnerable. Because I have a feeling I’m not the only one navigating this.

The New Job Where I Felt Like a Stranger

Back in June, I started a new job. And while the work itself has been fine, the social side of it has been unexpectedly challenging. I’ll be honest…I have struggled. I don’t mean “a little uncomfortable.” I mean, deeply out of place.

I sometimes feel a little out of sync with everyone around me. Not in a dramatic way, just in that subtle, “I’m new here and still trying to find my rhythm” way. Most people already have their circles. Their inside jokes. Their friend groups and their comfort zones. Stepping into that as the new person can feel intimidating. It’s like, I’m the new girl trying to find a place to stand without looking awkward.

I’m basically in a department of my own, which sounds peaceful but is actually lonely. I don’t have coworkers in my direct area, so those natural day-to-day conversations that usually spark friendships? They don’t happen. 

It’s not that anyone has been unkind; it’s simply that I’m still figuring out where I fit and how to be myself in a place where everything is new. And as someone who values connection, it’s uncomfortable to feel like you’re on the outside looking in. I sometimes wonder if people think I’m quiet or standoffish, when the truth is that I’m just trying to find my footing. I’m really not stuck-up. I’m just trying to honor Jesus in a setting where that stands out like a sore thumb.

My faith plays a big role in how I move through the world, and sometimes that makes me feel even more aware of how different everyone’s backgrounds and priorities can be. It’s not a matter of better or worse…just different. I try to enter every day with kindness, warmth, and the love of Jesus in my heart. More than once, I’ve caught myself thinking:

“If fitting in requires me to become someone I’m not, then maybe I’m not supposed to fit in.”

And I know that’s true. But the human part of me still longs for connection. To have a friend at work, to feel included, to not always feel like the odd one out. So every day has felt like a tug-of-war between loneliness and conviction. Between wanting to belong and wanting to be obedient. Between fitting in with people and standing firm with Jesus. I’m learning how to work that out in an environment where building relationships just takes more time. Some days, I’ve had to remind myself that it’s okay to be the newcomer. It’s okay to grow slowly. And it’s okay to be yourself while you’re learning the culture of a place.

The more I prayed about it, the more I realized something: feeling this way doesn’t mean I’m failing at friendship. It simply means I’m human. And this season pushed me to reflect on where I do feel connected and where God has been opening doors in ways I didn’t expect.

Jesus Understands This Feeling More Than We Realize

Here’s something that’s comforted me: Jesus knows exactly what it feels like to be misunderstood, rejected, and different. He lived in a world where His values rarely matched the culture. He loved people who didn’t love Him back. He kept showing up even when no one “got” Him. When I feel invisible or out of place, He gently reminds me:

“I see you. I know you. I’m with you.”

And Scripture has been hitting differently lately:

“By this everyone will know that you are my disciples, if you love one another.” — John 13:35

“Let us consider how we may spur one another on toward love and good deeds.” — Hebrews 10:24

“Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their toil. For if they fall, one will lift up his fellow. But woe to him who is alone when he falls and has not another to lift him up.” — Ecclesiastes 4:9–10

Friendship matters to God. Community matters to God. And even though the enemy uses isolation to wear us down, Jesus uses sisterhood to build us up.

The Courage to Stop Waiting and Start Saying Hello

While work has felt a bit lonely at times, church has been the complete opposite. One day, I realized something painful: I spent my whole life waiting for people to include me. Waiting for someone to say hello first, waiting for invitations, waiting to be noticed. And I was tired of waiting. I reached a point where I realized that waiting for people to approach me wasn’t working anymore. 

One Sunday morning, I felt this tug on my heart, almost like God whispering, “Go first.” I thought, “We all love Jesus. What’s the worst that could happen if I say hello first?”

So I did something that stretched me: I started saying hello to people. Simple as that. I’d pick one person each week and check in on them the next time I saw them. I’m not naturally bold in this area, so sometimes it felt awkward and out of my comfort zone, but it also felt right. Little by little, those small conversations started turning into something more genuine. So every Sunday, I would greet at least one new person, even if it felt awkward, even if my voice shook, even if my introverted heart was screaming.

And guess what? It worked. One woman in particular became a regular part of my Sundays. I’d ask how she was doing, she’d ask about my week, and over time, a real friendship grew. It’s the kind of connection I’m incredibly thankful for. The kind that makes you grateful you pushed through the awkwardness. One that reminds me that small steps can lead to meaningful relationships.

I also signed up for a serving position at church, even though I wasn’t totally sure about it. I figured, why not step into something new and see what God does with it? And wouldn’t you know…that simple “yes” opened the door to more connection than I expected.

In addition to that, I made it a priority to attend women’s events even when it would’ve been easier to hide at home. All of those tiny steps snowballed into something beautiful. Between serving and attending the women’s gatherings whenever my schedule allowed, I began to feel plugged in, supported, and surrounded by people who understood my heart. It made me realize something important: friendship often grows in the spaces where we choose to show up, even when we feel unsure. Sometimes we’re waiting for connection, but connection is waiting for us to take the first step. I now have new friends at church and a sense of belonging I didn’t know how much I needed. Work still feels lonely sometimes, but God showed me I am capable of forming friendships. I just needed to stop waiting and start walking toward people.

Why Adult Friendships Are So Hard: The Honest Reasons

As I’ve been walking through this season, I’ve been thinking a lot about why friendship feels so complicated for so many women. After talking with other women, here’s what I’ve learned: it’s not just me. It’s not just you. It’s all of us.

I believe part of it is that we overthink everything! Our words, our timing, our presence. “Did I sound weird?” “Should I text her again?” “Do I seem needy?” We talk ourselves out of connection before it even starts.

We’re tired and stretched thin. Work, kids, marriage, schedules, etc.. Sometimes friendship feels like one more demand.

We’ve experienced hurt in the past. Maybe it’s church hurt, relationship wounds, or women who betrayed our trust. Vulnerability feels risky.  We’re cautious now. We carry the scars of friendships that broke us. In our 30’s and 40’s, rejection just hurts differently.

Our values don’t match the culture. For Christian women, this is huge. Even in normal environments, we often feel “different.” Not because we’re better, but because Jesus has transformed us.

And we’re all juggling different responsibilities that make consistency hard, even when the desire for connection is there. 

None of this means we’re broken. It just means we’re human.

But I also believe this: God cares deeply about our relationships. He wired us for community. Scripture tells us that two are better than one, that we’re meant to encourage one another, and that love is how people recognize His presence in us. That tells me that friendship isn’t just a want, it’s a need. And it’s something worth pursuing, even when it feels awkward or uncertain.

So What Do We Do? Faith + Practical Tips

If you’re reading this and you’ve been feeling lonely, left out, or unsure of how to build friendships at this stage of life, I want you to know you aren’t alone. So many of us are navigating this quietly. And even though we don’t talk about it nearly enough, it’s something most women experience at one point or another.

Here are a few things the Lord is teaching me:

Start small…really small! One hello, one text, one conversation. It doesn’t have to be big to matter. A simple “hello” can open a door. 

Pray for God to show you who might need a friend. Sometimes the woman standing alone is praying for someone just like you.

Remember: friendships grow slowly. We want instant connection, but real friendships take time, consistency, and vulnerability.

Let your values be a filter, not a wall. Don’t hide who you are. Let your light gently shine. The right people will be drawn to it. And remember that you can be yourself while still stepping outside your comfort zone.

Be the person YOU needed as a friend. Be willing to go first. Be someone who smiles first, who asks, “How are you really?” Be the woman who makes room at her table. Friendship isn’t about being perfect. It’s about being present.

You’re Not Alone, Friend

Friendship in adulthood isn’t always easy, but it’s absolutely worth the effort. And the beautiful part? Jesus walks every step of this with us, strengthening us, guiding us, and reminding us that we don’t have to navigate these seasons alone. If you’re struggling to make friends right now, at work, in church, in your community, I see you. More importantly, Jesus sees you. 

You’re not “too much.”
You’re not “too different.”
You’re not “too hard to love.”

You’re just a woman trying to follow Jesus in a world that often doesn’t understand Him. And that’s a beautiful thing. Friendship is worth pursuing. Community is worth the effort. And the small, brave steps you take today might become the relationships that change your life.

And remember…you’re welcome at my table. Always. ❤️

If you’d like more faith-filled encouragement like this, plus recipes, weekly reflections, and real-life conversations, I’d love to have you in my newsletter community. It’s where I share the things that are on my heart in a deeper way. The things I don’t always post publicly. The real-life stuff, the heart work, and the little pieces of hope that get me through the week.

Processing…
Success! You're on the list.


Discover more from Just Being Kara

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from Just Being Kara

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading